Read the following passage and answer the question.
A clinical trial of a new rehabilitation programme reported a substantial improvement among participants who completed all twelve sessions. The finding attracted attention because the programme required less equipment than conventional therapy. Yet almost one third of those originally assigned to the programme had stopped attending before the final assessment. Some had moved away, while others reported that the exercises were difficult to maintain alongside work. The published average was calculated only from those who returned for the last test. This does not mean that the programme was ineffective. It does mean that the reported improvement cannot automatically be attributed to every person who enrolled. Participants who remained may have been healthier, more motivated or less constrained by time from the beginning. The investigators could compare the initial characteristics of completers and non-completers, examine why people withdrew and report outcomes under more than one reasonable assumption about missing data. None of these steps would recover an unobserved result with certainty, but they would reveal how dependent the conclusion is on who remained in the study. A larger trial with better follow-up might also help distinguish the programme's benefit from the effects of selective participation.
Which issue most seriously limits the interpretation of the published improvement?
- A) The programme was designed to use less equipment than conventional therapy.
- B) The result was based only on those who completed the final assessment.
- C) Some participants considered the exercises compatible with their working lives.
- D) The researchers initially assigned participants to a rehabilitation programme.
- E) Conventional rehabilitation generally involves more complex physical equipment.
Doğru cevap: B
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: B. Ortalamaya yalnız son teste katılanların alınması seçilim yanlılığı yaratabilir; başlangıçtaki tüm katılımcıların benzer düzeyde iyileştiği söylenemez.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A clinical trial of a new rehabilitation programme reported a substantial improvement among participants who completed all twelve sessions. The finding attracted attention because the programme required less equipment than conventional therapy. Yet almost one third of those originally assigned to the programme had stopped attending before the final assessment. Some had moved away, while others reported that the exercises were difficult to maintain alongside work. The published average was calculated only from those who returned for the last test. This does not mean that the programme was ineffective. It does mean that the reported improvement cannot automatically be attributed to every person who enrolled. Participants who remained may have been healthier, more motivated or less constrained by time from the beginning. The investigators could compare the initial characteristics of completers and non-completers, examine why people withdrew and report outcomes under more than one reasonable assumption about missing data. None of these steps would recover an unobserved result with certainty, but they would reveal how dependent the conclusion is on who remained in the study. A larger trial with better follow-up might also help distinguish the programme's benefit from the effects of selective participation.
Which conclusion is most consistent with the author's position?
- A) The programme may help, but the available result does not establish its effect for all enrollees.
- B) The programme definitely had no positive effect on any participant who withdrew.
- C) Every person who completed the trial must have been healthier initially.
- D) The dropout rate proves that equipment requirements determine treatment success.
- E) Missing outcomes can always be reconstructed exactly through statistical methods.
Doğru cevap: A
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: A. Yazar programın etkisiz olduğunu söylemez; yalnızca tamamlayanlarda gözlenen yararın bütün kayıtlı kişilere kesin biçimde genellenemeyeceğini belirtir.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A clinical trial of a new rehabilitation programme reported a substantial improvement among participants who completed all twelve sessions. The finding attracted attention because the programme required less equipment than conventional therapy. Yet almost one third of those originally assigned to the programme had stopped attending before the final assessment. Some had moved away, while others reported that the exercises were difficult to maintain alongside work. The published average was calculated only from those who returned for the last test. This does not mean that the programme was ineffective. It does mean that the reported improvement cannot automatically be attributed to every person who enrolled. Participants who remained may have been healthier, more motivated or less constrained by time from the beginning. The investigators could compare the initial characteristics of completers and non-completers, examine why people withdrew and report outcomes under more than one reasonable assumption about missing data. None of these steps would recover an unobserved result with certainty, but they would reveal how dependent the conclusion is on who remained in the study. A larger trial with better follow-up might also help distinguish the programme's benefit from the effects of selective participation.
Why might comparing initial characteristics be informative?
- A) It can guarantee that no participant's outcome was influenced by the programme.
- B) It can replace the missing final assessments with directly observed measurements.
- C) It can prove that moving away was the only reason for all withdrawals.
- D) It can eliminate the need to report how many participants originally enrolled.
- E) It can reveal whether those who remained differed systematically from those who left.
Doğru cevap: E
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: E. Başlangıç farklarını karşılaştırmak kalan grubun zaten daha sağlıklı veya motive olup olmadığını göstererek sonuçların seçilime duyarlılığını anlamaya yardım eder.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A clinical trial of a new rehabilitation programme reported a substantial improvement among participants who completed all twelve sessions. The finding attracted attention because the programme required less equipment than conventional therapy. Yet almost one third of those originally assigned to the programme had stopped attending before the final assessment. Some had moved away, while others reported that the exercises were difficult to maintain alongside work. The published average was calculated only from those who returned for the last test. This does not mean that the programme was ineffective. It does mean that the reported improvement cannot automatically be attributed to every person who enrolled. Participants who remained may have been healthier, more motivated or less constrained by time from the beginning. The investigators could compare the initial characteristics of completers and non-completers, examine why people withdrew and report outcomes under more than one reasonable assumption about missing data. None of these steps would recover an unobserved result with certainty, but they would reveal how dependent the conclusion is on who remained in the study. A larger trial with better follow-up might also help distinguish the programme's benefit from the effects of selective participation.
What does the passage imply about analyses based on missing-data assumptions?
- A) They always identify the precise outcome of each participant who left early.
- B) They should be avoided because incomplete data can never be analysed.
- C) They prove that all missing outcomes are identical to completed outcomes.
- D) They can test how sensitive a conclusion is, but cannot create certain observations.
- E) They eliminate the need to investigate participants' reasons for leaving.
Doğru cevap: D
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: D. Metin eksik verilere ilişkin makul varsayımların sonucun dayanıklılığını gösterdiğini, ancak gözlenmemiş bireysel sonuçları kesin olarak geri getirmediğini söyler.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A clinical trial of a new rehabilitation programme reported a substantial improvement among participants who completed all twelve sessions. The finding attracted attention because the programme required less equipment than conventional therapy. Yet almost one third of those originally assigned to the programme had stopped attending before the final assessment. Some had moved away, while others reported that the exercises were difficult to maintain alongside work. The published average was calculated only from those who returned for the last test. This does not mean that the programme was ineffective. It does mean that the reported improvement cannot automatically be attributed to every person who enrolled. Participants who remained may have been healthier, more motivated or less constrained by time from the beginning. The investigators could compare the initial characteristics of completers and non-completers, examine why people withdrew and report outcomes under more than one reasonable assumption about missing data. None of these steps would recover an unobserved result with certainty, but they would reveal how dependent the conclusion is on who remained in the study. A larger trial with better follow-up might also help distinguish the programme's benefit from the effects of selective participation.
What would most directly strengthen a future study of the programme?
- A) Reporting only the participants who achieved the largest individual gains.
- B) Excluding all people who have jobs before recruitment begins.
- C) Following a greater share of participants through the final assessment.
- D) Avoiding any record of why participants miss scheduled sessions.
- E) Assuming that everyone who leaves would have experienced improvement.
Doğru cevap: C
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: C. Daha iyi takip, çalışma dışına çıkanların etkisini azaltarak müdahalenin gerçek etkisine ilişkin daha güçlü kanıt sağlar; yazar ayrıca daha büyük deney önerir.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
Two manufacturers announced that the carbon footprint of their operations had fallen, but the figures could not be compared without examining how each company drew its accounting boundary. The first reported emissions from fuel burned at its own facilities and electricity purchased for those facilities. The second also estimated emissions from materials supplied by other firms and from transporting finished products. Although both companies used the term 'carbon footprint', their totals described different parts of the production chain. One company's smaller number did not necessarily indicate that it produced goods with a smaller overall climate impact. The distinction becomes especially important when a business outsources an energy-intensive stage of production. Emissions may disappear from its direct operational total while continuing to occur elsewhere in the supply chain. This is not evidence that all outsourcing increases emissions; it is a warning that a change in reporting scope can be mistaken for a change in physical activity. Analysts therefore recommend stating the boundary, time period, measurement method and significant exclusions next to the reported total. Comparisons become more informative when the same categories are covered or when the missing categories are separately estimated. A single headline number, however precise it appears, cannot resolve differences in what was counted.
What is the main source of difficulty in comparing the two manufacturers?
- A) Neither company reported any information about electricity consumption.
- B) Their reported totals include different stages of production and supply.
- C) Both companies were required to measure exactly the same supply-chain activities.
- D) The two companies used completely unrelated definitions of greenhouse gases.
- E) Their products are made exclusively from identical materials and energy sources.
Doğru cevap: B
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: B. Şirketlerden biri yalnız kendi tesis ve elektrik kullanımını, diğeri tedarik ve taşımayı da dahil ediyor; farklı kapsamların toplamı doğrudan karşılaştırılamaz.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
Two manufacturers announced that the carbon footprint of their operations had fallen, but the figures could not be compared without examining how each company drew its accounting boundary. The first reported emissions from fuel burned at its own facilities and electricity purchased for those facilities. The second also estimated emissions from materials supplied by other firms and from transporting finished products. Although both companies used the term 'carbon footprint', their totals described different parts of the production chain. One company's smaller number did not necessarily indicate that it produced goods with a smaller overall climate impact. The distinction becomes especially important when a business outsources an energy-intensive stage of production. Emissions may disappear from its direct operational total while continuing to occur elsewhere in the supply chain. This is not evidence that all outsourcing increases emissions; it is a warning that a change in reporting scope can be mistaken for a change in physical activity. Analysts therefore recommend stating the boundary, time period, measurement method and significant exclusions next to the reported total. Comparisons become more informative when the same categories are covered or when the missing categories are separately estimated. A single headline number, however precise it appears, cannot resolve differences in what was counted.
What is the risk associated with outsourcing an energy-intensive activity?
- A) Emissions may move outside a firm's direct reported boundary without physically disappearing.
- B) All suppliers automatically use electricity generated entirely from renewable sources.
- C) A manufacturer becomes legally unable to report any carbon footprint after outsourcing.
- D) The environmental effect of transporting goods becomes irrelevant to all accounts.
- E) Every outsourced activity necessarily produces more emissions than internal production.
Doğru cevap: A
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: A. Üretim dış kaynakla yapılsa da emisyon başka bir işletmede oluşmaya devam edebilir; dar işletme sınırı bunları göstermeyerek yanıltıcı düşüş yaratabilir.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
Two manufacturers announced that the carbon footprint of their operations had fallen, but the figures could not be compared without examining how each company drew its accounting boundary. The first reported emissions from fuel burned at its own facilities and electricity purchased for those facilities. The second also estimated emissions from materials supplied by other firms and from transporting finished products. Although both companies used the term 'carbon footprint', their totals described different parts of the production chain. One company's smaller number did not necessarily indicate that it produced goods with a smaller overall climate impact. The distinction becomes especially important when a business outsources an energy-intensive stage of production. Emissions may disappear from its direct operational total while continuing to occur elsewhere in the supply chain. This is not evidence that all outsourcing increases emissions; it is a warning that a change in reporting scope can be mistaken for a change in physical activity. Analysts therefore recommend stating the boundary, time period, measurement method and significant exclusions next to the reported total. Comparisons become more informative when the same categories are covered or when the missing categories are separately estimated. A single headline number, however precise it appears, cannot resolve differences in what was counted.
Which statement would the author most likely reject?
- A) Differences in accounting boundaries can undermine simple comparisons.
- B) Outsourcing can alter where emissions appear in company reports.
- C) Estimates are easier to compare when they cover matching activities.
- D) Companies should clearly describe what is included in their estimates.
- E) A smaller reported operational total proves a smaller overall climate impact.
Doğru cevap: E
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: E. Yazar daha küçük operasyonel toplamın mutlaka daha küçük bütüncül iklim etkisi anlamına gelmediğini özellikle vurgular.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
Two manufacturers announced that the carbon footprint of their operations had fallen, but the figures could not be compared without examining how each company drew its accounting boundary. The first reported emissions from fuel burned at its own facilities and electricity purchased for those facilities. The second also estimated emissions from materials supplied by other firms and from transporting finished products. Although both companies used the term 'carbon footprint', their totals described different parts of the production chain. One company's smaller number did not necessarily indicate that it produced goods with a smaller overall climate impact. The distinction becomes especially important when a business outsources an energy-intensive stage of production. Emissions may disappear from its direct operational total while continuing to occur elsewhere in the supply chain. This is not evidence that all outsourcing increases emissions; it is a warning that a change in reporting scope can be mistaken for a change in physical activity. Analysts therefore recommend stating the boundary, time period, measurement method and significant exclusions next to the reported total. Comparisons become more informative when the same categories are covered or when the missing categories are separately estimated. A single headline number, however precise it appears, cannot resolve differences in what was counted.
Why does the passage mention that outsourcing does not always increase emissions?
- A) To prove that direct operational numbers already include all supply-chain emissions.
- B) To show that accounting boundaries never influence the meaning of a total.
- C) To dismiss the importance of identifying excluded production activities.
- D) To avoid turning a reporting limitation into an unsupported universal causal claim.
- E) To argue that all outsourced production must be excluded from environmental studies.
Doğru cevap: D
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: D. Yazar kapsam kaymasının fiziksel değişimle karıştırılmaması gerektiğini söyler; buradan dış kaynak kullanımının daima emisyon artırdığı sonucu çıkarılmasın diye sınır koyar.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
Two manufacturers announced that the carbon footprint of their operations had fallen, but the figures could not be compared without examining how each company drew its accounting boundary. The first reported emissions from fuel burned at its own facilities and electricity purchased for those facilities. The second also estimated emissions from materials supplied by other firms and from transporting finished products. Although both companies used the term 'carbon footprint', their totals described different parts of the production chain. One company's smaller number did not necessarily indicate that it produced goods with a smaller overall climate impact. The distinction becomes especially important when a business outsources an energy-intensive stage of production. Emissions may disappear from its direct operational total while continuing to occur elsewhere in the supply chain. This is not evidence that all outsourcing increases emissions; it is a warning that a change in reporting scope can be mistaken for a change in physical activity. Analysts therefore recommend stating the boundary, time period, measurement method and significant exclusions next to the reported total. Comparisons become more informative when the same categories are covered or when the missing categories are separately estimated. A single headline number, however precise it appears, cannot resolve differences in what was counted.
Which practice would make comparisons more defensible?
- A) Ignoring the reporting period whenever totals are expressed as precise numbers.
- B) Including only those activities that make the company's reported total smallest.
- C) Reporting matching emissions categories or estimating significant omissions separately.
- D) Replacing all documented emissions categories with a single undefined label.
- E) Comparing the headline figures without asking what each one measures.
Doğru cevap: C
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: C. Paragraf benzer kategorileri kapsayan hesapların karşılaştırılmasını veya eksiklerin ayrıca tahmin edilmesini, sınır ve yöntemin açık bildirilmesini önerir.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A machine-learning system developed to predict complications after surgery achieved high accuracy in the hospital where it was trained. When another hospital considered adopting it, its administrators initially assumed that this result would transfer with little change. The patient population at the new hospital, however, was older on average, and laboratory results were recorded at different intervals. Some variables available to the original model were also missing for many new patients. In a preliminary test, the model still ranked higher-risk patients above lower-risk patients reasonably well, but its predicted probabilities were often too low. A patient assigned a ten-percent risk, for example, could belong to a group whose observed rate was substantially higher. The researchers distinguished this problem of calibration from the ability to rank patients. They also cautioned that good overall performance could conceal larger errors for certain patient groups. Before deployment, the hospital therefore planned to examine calibration across subgroups, investigate missing measurements and assess whether a locally adjusted model improved estimates on a separate validation sample. Adjusting probabilities using the same small dataset on which success is reported would provide an overly optimistic picture. The original accuracy figure remained informative about the first hospital; it was not a promise of identical clinical performance elsewhere.
Which distinction is central to the passage?
- A) Good performance at one hospital guarantees identical results at another.
- B) A model may rank patients reasonably well while giving poorly calibrated probabilities.
- C) Missing measurements necessarily make every risk estimate exactly zero.
- D) A model cannot use laboratory data unless every patient is the same age.
- E) Predictive systems always provide accurate probabilities when their rankings are correct.
Doğru cevap: B
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: B. Metin risk sıralamasının kabul edilebilir olmasına rağmen olasılık tahminlerinin sistemli biçimde düşük kalabileceğini; sıralama ve kalibrasyonun ayrı olduğunu vurgular.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A machine-learning system developed to predict complications after surgery achieved high accuracy in the hospital where it was trained. When another hospital considered adopting it, its administrators initially assumed that this result would transfer with little change. The patient population at the new hospital, however, was older on average, and laboratory results were recorded at different intervals. Some variables available to the original model were also missing for many new patients. In a preliminary test, the model still ranked higher-risk patients above lower-risk patients reasonably well, but its predicted probabilities were often too low. A patient assigned a ten-percent risk, for example, could belong to a group whose observed rate was substantially higher. The researchers distinguished this problem of calibration from the ability to rank patients. They also cautioned that good overall performance could conceal larger errors for certain patient groups. Before deployment, the hospital therefore planned to examine calibration across subgroups, investigate missing measurements and assess whether a locally adjusted model improved estimates on a separate validation sample. Adjusting probabilities using the same small dataset on which success is reported would provide an overly optimistic picture. The original accuracy figure remained informative about the first hospital; it was not a promise of identical clinical performance elsewhere.
What does the example of a predicted ten-percent risk illustrate?
- A) The predicted probability can underestimate the actual rate in a comparable patient group.
- B) A low reported probability proves that no complications were observed.
- C) Predictions from the first hospital contained no information of value.
- D) The model must have assigned every patient precisely the same risk score.
- E) The new hospital treated only patients with no risk of complications.
Doğru cevap: A
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: A. Yüzde on tahminine sahip grubun gerçekleşen oranı daha yüksek olabiliyor; bu olasılıkların kalibrasyon sorununu somutlaştırır.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A machine-learning system developed to predict complications after surgery achieved high accuracy in the hospital where it was trained. When another hospital considered adopting it, its administrators initially assumed that this result would transfer with little change. The patient population at the new hospital, however, was older on average, and laboratory results were recorded at different intervals. Some variables available to the original model were also missing for many new patients. In a preliminary test, the model still ranked higher-risk patients above lower-risk patients reasonably well, but its predicted probabilities were often too low. A patient assigned a ten-percent risk, for example, could belong to a group whose observed rate was substantially higher. The researchers distinguished this problem of calibration from the ability to rank patients. They also cautioned that good overall performance could conceal larger errors for certain patient groups. Before deployment, the hospital therefore planned to examine calibration across subgroups, investigate missing measurements and assess whether a locally adjusted model improved estimates on a separate validation sample. Adjusting probabilities using the same small dataset on which success is reported would provide an overly optimistic picture. The original accuracy figure remained informative about the first hospital; it was not a promise of identical clinical performance elsewhere.
Why does the passage call for subgroup analysis?
- A) The model should be judged solely by the largest patient group available.
- B) Local adjustments can only be made if there are no differences between hospitals.
- C) Subgroup comparisons automatically remove every missing laboratory measurement.
- D) All patient groups are assumed to have identical baseline complication rates.
- E) Overall performance may conceal greater errors for particular patient categories.
Doğru cevap: E
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: E. İyi bir toplu başarı puanı belirli hasta alt gruplarındaki büyük hataları gizleyebileceğinden performansın gruplar bazında incelenmesi gerekir.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A machine-learning system developed to predict complications after surgery achieved high accuracy in the hospital where it was trained. When another hospital considered adopting it, its administrators initially assumed that this result would transfer with little change. The patient population at the new hospital, however, was older on average, and laboratory results were recorded at different intervals. Some variables available to the original model were also missing for many new patients. In a preliminary test, the model still ranked higher-risk patients above lower-risk patients reasonably well, but its predicted probabilities were often too low. A patient assigned a ten-percent risk, for example, could belong to a group whose observed rate was substantially higher. The researchers distinguished this problem of calibration from the ability to rank patients. They also cautioned that good overall performance could conceal larger errors for certain patient groups. Before deployment, the hospital therefore planned to examine calibration across subgroups, investigate missing measurements and assess whether a locally adjusted model improved estimates on a separate validation sample. Adjusting probabilities using the same small dataset on which success is reported would provide an overly optimistic picture. The original accuracy figure remained informative about the first hospital; it was not a promise of identical clinical performance elsewhere.
Why is a separate validation sample recommended after local adjustment?
- A) Every independent sample necessarily produces the same performance figures.
- B) The initial training hospital must approve each prediction before it is made.
- C) Using separate data ensures that no patient will ever experience complications.
- D) Testing on the adjustment data alone can exaggerate the apparent improvement.
- E) An adjustment sample cannot contain laboratory observations from real patients.
Doğru cevap: D
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: D. Aynı küçük veriye uyarlayıp aynı veriyle başarı ölçmek aşırı iyimserliğe yol açabilir; ayrı örneklem uyarlamanın genellenebilirliğini sınar.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A machine-learning system developed to predict complications after surgery achieved high accuracy in the hospital where it was trained. When another hospital considered adopting it, its administrators initially assumed that this result would transfer with little change. The patient population at the new hospital, however, was older on average, and laboratory results were recorded at different intervals. Some variables available to the original model were also missing for many new patients. In a preliminary test, the model still ranked higher-risk patients above lower-risk patients reasonably well, but its predicted probabilities were often too low. A patient assigned a ten-percent risk, for example, could belong to a group whose observed rate was substantially higher. The researchers distinguished this problem of calibration from the ability to rank patients. They also cautioned that good overall performance could conceal larger errors for certain patient groups. Before deployment, the hospital therefore planned to examine calibration across subgroups, investigate missing measurements and assess whether a locally adjusted model improved estimates on a separate validation sample. Adjusting probabilities using the same small dataset on which success is reported would provide an overly optimistic picture. The original accuracy figure remained informative about the first hospital; it was not a promise of identical clinical performance elsewhere.
Which inference is best supported by the final sentence?
- A) Older patients always require more frequent laboratory measurements.
- B) The new hospital can safely use the model without any further assessment.
- C) Performance evidence is tied to the setting and population in which it was obtained.
- D) The original accuracy estimate was meaningless even in the first hospital.
- E) Models trained in hospitals should never be evaluated in other institutions.
Doğru cevap: C
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: C. Son cümle ilk hastanede elde edilen başarı bilgisinin değerli ama başka koşullarda aynı sonucu garanti etmeyen bağlama özgü bir kanıt olduğunu ifade eder.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
After a new flood barrier was built, the centre of a riverside city experienced less damage during two periods of unusually heavy rainfall. Local officials described the barrier as a major success, and the observations did suggest that it had protected the buildings immediately behind it. Hydrologists, however, questioned whether the project had reduced flood risk for the river system as a whole. Water that could no longer spread onto the protected floodplain might be diverted or move more quickly towards communities farther downstream. A lower damage figure in the city centre would not reveal those possible effects. Moreover, the two storms differed in duration and upstream conditions from earlier events, so a simple before-and-after comparison could not isolate the barrier's contribution. The researchers proposed combining measurements of water levels at multiple points with models tested against past floods. They also called for evidence about property damage and exposure in downstream settlements. Even such an assessment would contain uncertainty, since a model cannot reproduce every future storm. The aim was not to deny the benefit to protected residents but to determine whether the project had lowered regional risk, transferred some of it, or done both. Decisions about additional barriers would be stronger if those outcomes were distinguished.
What is the hydrologists' principal concern?
- A) Local officials have refused to acknowledge all changes in flood exposure.
- B) Protection of the centre may shift flood risk to communities farther downstream.
- C) The barrier has certainly failed to protect any buildings in the city centre.
- D) Floodwater cannot move through a river after any barrier is constructed.
- E) The number of rainy days is identical in every year of the study.
Doğru cevap: B
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: B. Hidrologlar merkezdeki yararı reddetmez; suyun aşağı yerleşimlere yönelmesiyle bölgesel riskin yalnız yer değiştirmiş olabileceğini sorgular.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
After a new flood barrier was built, the centre of a riverside city experienced less damage during two periods of unusually heavy rainfall. Local officials described the barrier as a major success, and the observations did suggest that it had protected the buildings immediately behind it. Hydrologists, however, questioned whether the project had reduced flood risk for the river system as a whole. Water that could no longer spread onto the protected floodplain might be diverted or move more quickly towards communities farther downstream. A lower damage figure in the city centre would not reveal those possible effects. Moreover, the two storms differed in duration and upstream conditions from earlier events, so a simple before-and-after comparison could not isolate the barrier's contribution. The researchers proposed combining measurements of water levels at multiple points with models tested against past floods. They also called for evidence about property damage and exposure in downstream settlements. Even such an assessment would contain uncertainty, since a model cannot reproduce every future storm. The aim was not to deny the benefit to protected residents but to determine whether the project had lowered regional risk, transferred some of it, or done both. Decisions about additional barriers would be stronger if those outcomes were distinguished.
Why is the reduction in city-centre damage insufficient to prove a regional benefit?
- A) It does not measure possible changes in flood damage and exposure elsewhere.
- B) It shows that all future rainfall will be weaker than the observed storms.
- C) It guarantees that downstream settlements suffered no additional exposure.
- D) It demonstrates that the barrier has no measurable effect on any location.
- E) It is based on a comparison of identical storms under the same conditions.
Doğru cevap: A
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: A. Merkezde azalan hasar, suyun aşağı havzadaki etkisini göstermez; bölgesel net yarar için diğer yerlerdeki maruziyet ve hasar ölçülmelidir.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
After a new flood barrier was built, the centre of a riverside city experienced less damage during two periods of unusually heavy rainfall. Local officials described the barrier as a major success, and the observations did suggest that it had protected the buildings immediately behind it. Hydrologists, however, questioned whether the project had reduced flood risk for the river system as a whole. Water that could no longer spread onto the protected floodplain might be diverted or move more quickly towards communities farther downstream. A lower damage figure in the city centre would not reveal those possible effects. Moreover, the two storms differed in duration and upstream conditions from earlier events, so a simple before-and-after comparison could not isolate the barrier's contribution. The researchers proposed combining measurements of water levels at multiple points with models tested against past floods. They also called for evidence about property damage and exposure in downstream settlements. Even such an assessment would contain uncertainty, since a model cannot reproduce every future storm. The aim was not to deny the benefit to protected residents but to determine whether the project had lowered regional risk, transferred some of it, or done both. Decisions about additional barriers would be stronger if those outcomes were distinguished.
What complicates a simple before-and-after comparison of the storms?
- A) Local residents had previously experienced flooding in the area.
- B) The researchers used the same units for water levels in all observations.
- C) The barrier was built before the two heavy-rainfall periods occurred.
- D) Officials collected information about buildings behind the barrier.
- E) The events differed in duration and upstream conditions.
Doğru cevap: E
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: E. Fırtınaların süresi ve yukarı havza koşulları farklıdır; bu değişkenler kontrol edilmeden hasar farkının tamamı bariyere atfedilemez.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
After a new flood barrier was built, the centre of a riverside city experienced less damage during two periods of unusually heavy rainfall. Local officials described the barrier as a major success, and the observations did suggest that it had protected the buildings immediately behind it. Hydrologists, however, questioned whether the project had reduced flood risk for the river system as a whole. Water that could no longer spread onto the protected floodplain might be diverted or move more quickly towards communities farther downstream. A lower damage figure in the city centre would not reveal those possible effects. Moreover, the two storms differed in duration and upstream conditions from earlier events, so a simple before-and-after comparison could not isolate the barrier's contribution. The researchers proposed combining measurements of water levels at multiple points with models tested against past floods. They also called for evidence about property damage and exposure in downstream settlements. Even such an assessment would contain uncertainty, since a model cannot reproduce every future storm. The aim was not to deny the benefit to protected residents but to determine whether the project had lowered regional risk, transferred some of it, or done both. Decisions about additional barriers would be stronger if those outcomes were distinguished.
What does the author suggest about hydrological models?
- A) They should be used without comparison against any recorded past floods.
- B) They accurately predict every detail of every storm that has yet to occur.
- C) They are unnecessary whenever photographs show less visible damage.
- D) They can inform assessment but cannot remove all uncertainty about future floods.
- E) They can prove that water cannot be redirected towards other communities.
Doğru cevap: D
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: D. Metin geçmiş taşkınlarla sınanmış modellerin yararlı olacağını, buna rağmen gelecekteki her fırtınayı kusursuz canlandıramayacağını belirtir.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
After a new flood barrier was built, the centre of a riverside city experienced less damage during two periods of unusually heavy rainfall. Local officials described the barrier as a major success, and the observations did suggest that it had protected the buildings immediately behind it. Hydrologists, however, questioned whether the project had reduced flood risk for the river system as a whole. Water that could no longer spread onto the protected floodplain might be diverted or move more quickly towards communities farther downstream. A lower damage figure in the city centre would not reveal those possible effects. Moreover, the two storms differed in duration and upstream conditions from earlier events, so a simple before-and-after comparison could not isolate the barrier's contribution. The researchers proposed combining measurements of water levels at multiple points with models tested against past floods. They also called for evidence about property damage and exposure in downstream settlements. Even such an assessment would contain uncertainty, since a model cannot reproduce every future storm. The aim was not to deny the benefit to protected residents but to determine whether the project had lowered regional risk, transferred some of it, or done both. Decisions about additional barriers would be stronger if those outcomes were distinguished.
Which conclusion best captures the passage as a whole?
- A) Measuring property damage is unnecessary when a physical barrier already exists.
- B) A local reduction in damage is sufficient evidence that all flood risk has ended.
- C) Flood protection should be judged by local benefits and possible changes in wider-system risk.
- D) New flood barriers should always be built without assessing downstream areas.
- E) A project cannot protect any residents unless every future storm is predicted.
Doğru cevap: C
Çözüm: Doğru cevap: C. Son bölüm proje değerlendirmesinin merkezdeki korumayla sınırlanmaması, bölgesel riskin azalma ve yer değiştirme olasılıklarını ayırması gerektiğini savunur.